MY PARKINSON’S DIARY
MY PARKINSON’S DIARY
TOP TEN FAVORITE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS (ANNOTATED)
Friday, March 6, 2015
February 7-8, 2015
Let me establish something up front: there is nothing I judge more harshly than a teacher who plays favorites. That said, I love breaking my own rules, so in the immediate aftermath of posting my Top Ten Favorite Things About Teaching, I hatched the idiotic scheme of listing my Top Ten Favorite Students by name with, of course, _______ _______ as #1. Fortunately for all concerned, it took no time at all for me to realize what a spectacularly bad notion that was, but almost immediately I landed upon the alternative idea you see below. If this list still results in bruised feelings, I apologize in advance; I ask you only semi-sarcastically to remember this is all part of the grieving process for me which culminated, after all, with #1 on my previous list. With that in mind, what follows is a list of my favorite students over the course of my career, defined by type as opposed to singled out by name.
And to the students who formed the basis of this list of types, please rest assured that while you may think you are the student being referred to in any given number, when a teacher has had as many students as I have, there is more than one example of each that comes to mind. Also, give yourself some credit for not being reduced to a simple stereotype: many's the day that I have seen the Lovable Slacker morph into Mr. (Or Ms. as the case may be) President or vice versa, not to mention The Acolyte who was simultaneously the Kindred Spirit while also racking up points as a Trouble Child. In fact, while I'm not quite sure I've ever seen anyone run the table -- that is, exhibit characteristics of all ten favorites -- I'm sure I could very easily summon up the images of any number of students who chalked up six or seven over the course of our time together.
So, all that said, here are my reflections on the joys (and challenges!) of working with ten very different students, often in the same classroom.
10. Future Colleague
With some students it becomes clear from the moment they take up residence in my classroom that they are destined to have rooms of their own someday. And that's a good thing, particularly when I get to feel as though I somehow inspired them to take up the noble profession. For others, it's like, "You're gonna do what?!? Good luck!!!" At which point, the poor dears invariably point toward me as inspiration. And for still more, the first time they show up at a faculty meeting it's living proof that anything is possible under the sun. Which, again, is a good thing as, for all my snark, I have seldom, if ever, met anyone who went into teaching for the wrong reasons.
9. Swinging Cat
Ya gotta love the swinging cats of this world. Sometimes it's a wee tad unnerving to think that someone that young could be that much cooler than I am, but the sad fact is that it's not just self deprecation to state that it's not that hard to be cooler than I am. In truth, it's a feat that became easier and easier as I moved through my fifties. About the time I realized that absolutely no hip hop was ever going to appeal to me, it became crystal clear that the best thing for me was to sit back and bask in the reflected glow of those swinging, swinging cats. And as I say ya gotta love them, if for no other reason than I was one once ... when dinosaurs walked the earth.
8. Lovable Slacker
Both words equally apply: as lovable as this student is, so to the same degree a slacker. The first part is what makes the package, though: despite the chronically missing homework, despite the resulting appallingly low tests scores, despite the fact that this student seems determined to play that 59.5% game, it's simply impossible to deny my love for this student . Because, you know, a grade is just a grade, but a high quality human being exists outside such parameters as cumulative GPA.
7. Mr. President
The Prez comes in a couple of sub-sets: El Presidente or Madam Presidente, which is to say a student who may be ruling the student council with an iron fist in any given year, and the far more rare but clearly more striking instance in which a student is clearly destined for the Oval Office, which is to say will someday actually be addressed as Mr. President, or in the only case I have been so fortunate to have in my classroom, President (last name rhymes with Holy Moley). The first of these is merely mockery, more or less aggressively so, depending, while the second was, simply put, a product of awe.
6. Home Girl
This student almost inevitably came with siblings who had frequented my classroom as well as parents whom I actually got to know as a result of exchanges at Parent-Teacher Conferences. If small town America does not rise or fall on the lives of its home girls, I'm going to want to know why. And for as much as this type can reflect even more than that in conjuring up a whole system of conformity, it takes all kinds to make up this wacky world of ours, and if for every Swinging Cat, there are an unknown multiple of Home Girls, that's not conformity at work so much as the natural order of things.
5. Trouble Child
I don't know why this student is on this list: it's not like I look forward to hearing of the inevitable OD. But some part of me wants to help the helpless, save any who can put up with saving, if only for a while. And almost every other student on this list has been a Trouble Child at one time or another; certainly the exalted title of El Presidente hasn't stopped it from happening, nor sadly has being a Kindred Spirit. And lest you think that Trouble always equals drugs, have I got a thing or three to tell you about being a teen. In fact, sometimes I think Trouble almost always comes from being in a family, but sometimes it seems that the only thing that comes from being in a family is being in a family. Whatever its source, I do know what to do about Trouble which is not to judge it, even while offering a listening ear.
4. Surrogate Daughter
This I have said more than once: If I had a daughter, I'd want her to be just like ___________ . It's almost always on the occasion of someone's last parent teacher conferences, and I will admit I've gotten some funny looks as a result. I suppose it might help if I told the parent sitting across the table from me how very much I had wanted girls when Julie and I had our children. But then I'd have to explain how three boys were a form of karma on me, and that would put me around two bends of a road that it might be better not to go down at all. But the truth is that those times when I've had the father-daughter love thing have been some of my very favorite moments in teaching.
3. The Worst
I'm smiling now, and it's not entirely because by retiring I ensured that I would never again experience the sensation of recognizing The Worst on the first day of school and realizing that I would be forced to deal with this person for the entire school year. I mean, sure, that's some of the reason for the goofy grin I wear at present, but the fact is that I can remember some of The Worsts more clearly and with more genuine warmth that I can the Presidents who crossed my threshold. There is just something about a person who is that much of a total fucking mess that makes me remember him (and let's face it, it was generally, though not absolutely always, a male) fondly. That's probably because I became a real evangelizer for The Power of Love over the course of my career which is to say that I came to believe fiercely in the efficacy of love in dealing with The Worst. I have absolutely no data to back this statement up, but if anything, that just reinforces its ultimate truth: There is nothing so conducive to learning than demonstrating the ability to love those whose nature has rendered them unlovable.
2. The Acolyte
A classic example of overlapping type, The Acolyte, is sometimes though not always a Kindred Spirit and Future Colleague. But it's a type worth contemplating in its own right, if only for the reality check against false modesty represented by declaring such a character a favorite. Yeah, I guess I might as well admit that I like it when people want to be like me. I suppose that's a natural human tendency. At the same time, if there's anything that'll keep you on the straight-and-narrow, it's the prospect of repaying a bit of hero worship with bad behavior. So go ahead, declare Yoda your guru to be; if nothing else, you'll help him to keep his nose clean.
1. Kindred Spirit
Thank God for the Kindred Spirits, the ones who really "get" it, whatever it may be: the fundamental lack of sociability that is the other side of teaching, what it means to have at least one person in the room laughing (or more likely smiling wryly) at all the right jokes, the beautiful thing that is having someone who is actually glad to see you come into work that day. Managing such relationships with students can be a tricky business. Maybe this is just me, but few things are more likely to make me throw up in my mouth than the prospect of someone saying "I don't want to just be your teacher, I want to be your friend." Even so, that more than once a Kindred Spirit has turned out to be a Future Colleague should come as no surprise. After all, it has seemed as though we were on equal footing from the beginning.
“I have absolutely no data to back this statement up, but if anything, that just reinforces its ultimate truth: There is nothing so conducive to learning than demonstrating the ability to love those whose nature has rendered them unlovable.”